Amid citizenship controversies and a petition to block her participation, Chidimma Adetshina’s Miss Universe journey exposes deep-seated debates on nationality, representation, and identity in South Africa.
Chidimma Adetshina, a 23-year-old Soweto-born South African citizen, gained attention when she reached the Top 30 in the Miss South Africa 2024 competition. Her journey in beauty pageants, however, took a controversial turn due to her Nigerian heritage and her mother’s alleged legal infractions involving immigration status. Following her withdrawal from the Miss South Africa competition, she went on to win Miss Universe Nigeria in September 2024, securing her place in the global Miss Universe pageant scheduled to take place in Mexico this November. Yet, the scrutiny has only intensified as critics argue she is unfit to represent Nigeria on such a high-profile platform.
The backlash first erupted when information surfaced that Adetshina’s mother, a Mozambican immigrant, had previously been involved in identity fraud, leading South African authorities to investigate the legitimacy of the family’s citizenship. Critics have alleged that Adetshina’s participation in Miss Universe as a Nigerian representative undermines the integrity of the competition and have taken action to prevent her participation.
On October 30, 2024, a South African organization known as the Progressive Forces of South Africa launched a petition on Change.org entitled, “Chidimma Adetshina should not participate in Miss Universe.” This petition quickly gained momentum, drawing over 1,000 signatures in a matter of hours. The group asserts that Adetshina’s potential involvement in Miss Universe could tarnish the reputation of the event, stating, “The Miss Universe brand should uphold values of integrity, authenticity, and fair competition.” The petitioners contend that Adetshina’s mother’s past should disqualify her from competing, citing how these legal allegations go against the values Miss Universe is meant to represent.
While the petition has attracted substantial support, Adetshina has also found defenders among those who view her as a symbol of multiculturalism in South Africa. Her supporters argue that she represents resilience and embodies the spirit of a diverse society. Adetshina’s case, they say, is emblematic of broader struggles against xenophobia, emphasizing that South African identity should not be narrowly defined by ethnic origin. One advocate shared, “She is as South African as anyone else born here. Her nationality should not be questioned based on her lineage but rather on her contributions to the nation and community.”
For critics, however, Adetshina’s heritage raises questions about the authenticity of her representation. Many claim that her Nigerian descent and her recent shift to compete as Miss Universe Nigeria detract from her South African identity. Some assert that South African representation in international forums should reflect a “truly South African” background, questioning whether Adetshina can genuinely embody the South African experience. “Her family’s past and her Nigerian nationality discredit her as a legitimate figure to represent either South Africa or Nigeria in the Miss Universe competition,” argued a signatory of the petition.
The controversy intensified as the Department of Home Affairs confirmed an investigation into the citizenship status of both Adetshina and her mother. On October 29, 2024, the department announced plans to revoke their South African identities due to evidence suggesting irregularities in their citizenship claims. The implications of this decision could severely impact Adetshina’s future as a public figure. Her eligibility to travel to Mexico was enabled by a Nigerian passport obtained following her withdrawal from Miss South Africa, further highlighting the duality of her status and complicating her bid to represent Nigeria on the global stage.
The Department of Home Affairs has taken a strong stance, indicating that, if successful, their legal action would nullify Adetshina’s claim to South African nationality, leaving her solely with her Nigerian identity.
For Adetshina, the journey to Miss Universe is one fraught with challenges. As she prepares to compete under the banner of Nigeria, the fallout from her mother’s legal history and the controversy surrounding her citizenship could impact her experience in the pageant. The debate has also attracted international attention, prompting discussions about the role of nationality in the global beauty industry. Supporters argue that beauty pageants should serve as platforms for cross-cultural exchange, with contestants representing not just their nations but also global diversity. Critics, however, maintain that such representation must adhere to strict standards, reflecting the values and aspirations of the countries represented.
The reactions on social media have been mixed, with many echoing the sentiments expressed in the petition, while others have rallied in Adetshina’s defense, praising her resilience. Public opinion in South Africa remains divided. Some argue that Adetshina’s unique background enriches the Miss Universe Nigeria title, while others claim it undermines the authenticity of national representation. “The Miss Universe platform is not just about beauty; it’s about representing a culture and a nation,” one online commentator stated, “and that responsibility should go to someone who is truly reflective of Nigeria’s values.”
The Miss Universe Organization has yet to issue an official statement, and it remains uncertain how they will address the escalating tensions surrounding her participation. As the November pageant approaches, all eyes are on both Adetshina and the Miss Universe Organization, watching how they will navigate this uniquely complex situation.
Join our Channel...